Our contest is over, check out the talent!

Our Best City in the World Contest has come to an end! We’re so excited to start compiling all the submissions and seeing what people came up with. (Backgrounder: in this contest, the Economist Intelligence Unit challenged the world to devise and visualize new ways to rank cities and measure urban liveability.)

You can check out — and in the case of interactive submissions, play with — many of the contest entries which have now been made public on our Best City Contest Topic page (which aggregates all the submissions). 

Some screenshots of the most recent submissions (picked for no specific reason):

Very impressive — great job, everyone!

Our Best City Contest deadline is coming …

                            

Have you been planning to submit a data visualization entry to our Best City in the World Contest and help the Economist Intelligence Unit find new ways to rank the world’s cities? Time is running out — don’t let your chance to win $10,000 slip away.

Submitting your entry correctly involves a few steps; make sure you get it to us properly so your efforts aren’t wasted. Take a few minutes to watch our submission guide video to ensure you know how:

                 

Best City in the World Contest Submission Guide from BuzzData on Vimeo.

How to Enter

First, read the Contest Rules. By participating in this contest, you agree to be bound by these rules. We also suggest that you bookmark this page and the Contest Rules page for future reference; please check back from time to time for any updates.

  1. Log in or sign up to BuzzData to download the two EIU datasets:
  2.  EIU 2011 Liveability Index

     EIU 2011 World Cost of Living Index

  3. Create a new dataset and name it in the format: “Best City Contest - < First Name > < Last Name >.”

    a. Upload your new dataset to BuzzData, making it “Private”. See BuzzData Help for guidance on doing this.

    b. Add the topic “Best City Contest” to the dataset (mandatory) and start to follow this topic (optional but we recommend it).

  4. Build your project on BuzzData - work on your dataset offline (e.g. mash it up with other, publicly-available data) and re-upload to take advantage of BuzzData’s excellent version control as you get it ready for submission.

  5. Produce a visualization of your dataset, using your visualization tool of choice, and associate it with your dataset. See BuzzData Help for guidance on adding visualizations to datasets.

  6. Create a document (PDF, Word or Pages document) that clearly identifies the best city and explains your approach and the value in your index (e.g. why you’ve weighted it as you have) (max 1,000 words). Upload it as an attachment to the dataset.

  7. When your dataset, visualization and document are ready for submission:

    a. Make the dataset “Public”. See BuzzData Help for guidance on doing this.

    b. Invite the user “BuzzJudge” to become a collaborator on your dataset. This will confirm your submission.


  8. All submissions (that have invited BuzzJudge as a collaborator) will be considered final at 11:59pm (PST) on March 4, 2012. Any subsequent updates to datasets will not be accepted as part of the submission.

  9. Drum up support for your submission by Tweeting about it, Liking it on Facebook, +1-ing on Google+, showcasing it on your blog or website using BuzzData’s badges, etc.

Best City Contest: only 1 weekend left!

Our ‘Best City in the World’ contest in partnership with the Economist Intelligence Unit forges ahead — there’s only one weekend left to submit your entry! The deadline fast approaches: March 4, 2012. If you’ve got data visualization skills and urban design knowledge to show off, don’t let the chance to redefine city liveability and win $10,000 slip past you. 

Some quick updates on the contest:

1) Eager data-visualization enthusiasts continue to iterate on the EIU’s liveability data sets on our Best City Contest topic page, mining for interesting and telling trends:

Some very interesting ways of interpreting the data are popping up — follow along and join the discussion!

2) One contestant recently asked us a question regarding climate vs. weather indicators in the EIU’s liveability index:

At “Category 3: Culture and environment” in the document “About Liveability Survey.doc”, the indicator Humidity/temperature rating is mentioned.

This indicator does not appear in the (liveability) spreadsheet, instead there is a “Climate rating” indicator.

Does this indicator relate climate in the sense of weather, and in that case which factors is this indicator taking into account?

EIU Cost of Living editor Jon Copestake clarified as follows:

The climate category has two indicators: a general comfort indicators supplied by the correspondent and also a quantitative indicator calculated from average weather conditions. The enquirer is right - these are the same indicator.”

To help further clarify, Copestake also passed along the EIU’s climate scoring methodology, which is now found under “Attachments” of the EIU’s contest liveability index data set.  

The EIU has been very open to answering contestant inquiries as completely as possible, so do take advantage! If you have a question, ask Copestake directly through a BuzzData private message or ask us at contest@buzzdata.com

Data-driven journalism, done faster

From the start, we went out of our way to enlist the participation of groups and businesses for the BuzzData beta — after all, BuzzData is all about improving group collaboration around data, right?

Having said that, bringing businesses on board at the beta stage, let alone post-commercial launch, is no small feat for a funky, outside-the-box app like BuzzData. The concept of open data is still relatively new, and simple workflow tools for data wrangling and sharing are rare. Finding organizations that were hip to the movement and up for trying a new, untested digital app was a fun challenge, needless to say.

Lucky for us, a small number of influential, forward-thinking organizations came forward to test the beta right at from start, including: 

The Economist Intelligence Unit 

The Globe and Mail (Canada’s national newspaper)

Global News (Canadian broadcast and online news)

The City of Vancouver

And while the beta’s only been active less than a week, we’ve already witnessed instances of unscripted cross-pollination between media, government and data-literate citizens. This is hugely exciting to us. 

The Globe and Mail’s account in particular, hosted by Toronto Hacks/Hackers organizer and Globe mobile editor Mason Wright, has been off to a promising start, largely because Wright clearly gets the give/take aspect of social networking, posting Globe articles to other users’ data and making an effort to put the Globe’s data in context with accompanying articles and visualizations.

It’s fascinating to watch this happen in the context of data. We’re so used to static catalogues and repositories that appear to move at a glacial pace. In contrast, on BuzzData you tell a user something — whether it’s your best friend or a national newspaper — and they talk back to you as a visible, dynamic, listening entity, a single degree of separation away. Not a new phenomenon to social media, certainly, but a refreshing change of pace for data communication. 

As an example, last week the Globe uploaded food price indices data as an accompaniment to a recent Report on Business article. The article itself focused on short-term food prices, but New York-based beta tester David Joerg took the data and, by simply plotting the data over time in Excel, uncovered a startling spike in sugar prices no one had yet noticed: 

Even Wright was surprised to see this. So the question remains: what’s driving the price inflation of sugar? Perhaps Joerg’s cursory data-viz will trigger an entirely new business investigation by the Globe in the near future. That would be incredibly cool, and a truly unique example of collaborative data journalism — one that, in an instant, transcended national boundaries and professional disciplines.

Not bad for the first five days of a beta.